SERMON: The One in the Middle

Matthew 25:14-30

Pastor Robyn Hogue June 9, 2013 Skyline Presbyterian Church

The point of the parable is virtually impossible to miss. The master entrusted his servants with talents (a significant amount of money in the ancient world—one talent was the rough equivalent of 15 years’ wages for the average worker). The servant who received five talents was wise; he invested his talents and doubled their value. The servant who buried his talent in the ground was foolish, and thereby lost what little he had.

Lots of lessons here: Be good stewards of your abilities. Use them or lose them. Don’t be afraid to try. Never say, “I have so little, my contribution won’t matter.” People may not be equal in talent but they can surely be equal in effort. You can probably think of a few others you have heard. The point is always obvious—those who follow Jesus are to seek to be like the wise, five-talent servant and not like the one-talent fool. Case closed.

OK. But there is one aspect of this story that troubles me if we close the case so quickly. What about the one in the middle, the two-talent guy? Is he superfluous? For that matter, were any of the characters in Jesus’ stories superfluous? I don’t think so. Yes, there was the wise, multi-talented servant as an example of excellent stewardship and a foolish, single-talented servant as an example of poor stewardship. But also there was this one in the middle, a person with a lot less than the “super” five-talent servant but one with a lot more than the hapless, one-talent servant. In my humble opinion, the one in the middle is there for an important purpose.

Let’s check him out. What do we know about the two-talent servant? Well, obviously he is somewhere in between the two others in terms of the master’s faith in his abilities. He has been entrusted with two talents—twice as much as the foolish servant. But he is only entrusted with two, which is just 40 percent as much as the wise, five-talent guy. Perhaps the master thought the one in the middle had some potential, but he was not considered likely to be a standout performer.

And what did the two-talent servant do with his two talents? He doubled them, and wound up returning four talents to the boss. His performance was, proportionately, on a par with that of the five-talent servant. He did just as well as the shining-star example in the parable.

Frankly, although the parable does not say it, I suspect that Jesus’ first audience was at least somewhat surprised when the master received four talents from the servant in the middle. We can assume that the master was astute, that is why he is the master in the story. The crowd probably expected the excellent performance from the five-talent servant. They also probably expected worthless performance from the one-talent servant although the master had deliberately entrusted the man with a talent in order to give him an opportunity to prove himself. But the two-talent servant’s performance was better than expected. If he had brought back, say three talents, that would have been a predictable, good showing for him. But performing at the same level as the top guy? Now that was something! When the master said “Well done, good and trustworthy servant...” to the one in the middle, I suspect his congratulation was just a little louder and just a little heartier than his comments to the other two.

Most of us are two-talent servants. We are not fools, idiots, wastrels of the riches of God. We realize that God has entrusted us with a great deal, so we are not going to foolishly hide, and completely fail to utilize what God has given into our care. On the other hand most of us are not superstars of the faith. Few of us are going to become Saint Pauls or John Calvins, or Mother Teresas. We are not likely to conduct crusades where millions are saved nor build cathedrals to God’s glory, nor offer our lives up in martyrdom on some foreign field for Christ. Somewhere smack in between the heights and depths is where most of us live—and the good news is, that is exactly where we can faithfully serve God. Not only can we serve, but we can serve well. Proportionately, we can utilize what has been entrusted to us just as effectively as the crusade conductors, the cathedral builders, the martyrs.

Starting is the first step to succeeding. We cannot be afraid of failure. It’s baseball season again so I can bring you this: in 1915 Ty Cobb set the record for stolen bases at 96. Seven years later, Max Carey became second best with 51 stolen bases. Does this mean that Cobb was twice as good as Carey, his closest rival?

Look at the facts: Cobb made 134 attempts, Carey, 53. Cobb failed 38 times; Carey only failed twice. Cobb succeeded 96 times, Carey only 51 times. Cobb’s average was only 71 percent. Carey’s average was 96 percent. Carey’s average was much better than Cobb’s. Cobb tried 81 more times than Carey. But here is the key: His 81 additional tries produced 44 more stolen bases. Cobb risked failure 81 more times in one season than his closest rival and Cobb held that record for over 60 years. Why? Because he tried.

The one in the middle, the faithful servant who does the best he or she possibly can with what has been given, is the one who tries. And the result is pleasing to the master and perhaps even surprisingly pleasing, to us.

Truit Gannon, pastor of a church in Georgia, tells of an incident in his boyhood. A man named Hugh, who worked for his father, owned a beautiful Harley Davidson motorcycle. It was a wine-colored machine with the hydro-glide fork on the front wheel. As I understand it, that hydro-glide fork was an engineering miracle in motorcycling in its day. Anyway, Pastor Gannon says it was his greatest thrill as a teenager to ride that motorcycle. One day he asked, “Hugh, can I ride your motorcycle again today?” Hugh’s words have stuck with him ever since. “You can ride it anytime you want to,” Hugh said, “anywhere you want to, and as often as you want to. Just remember to ride it like it was mine and not yours.” Reflecting on that statement, Pastor Gannon says, “God has given us full and free use of this world. All He asks is that we use it like it was His and not ours. That’s stewardship.”

Making Christ Lord means using our possessions, our abilities, influence, time and property for His glory. When He is Lord we recognize that we are to ride like life is His and not our own.